Episode

Mysteries of the Cosmos, From Dark Energy to the Big Bang: A State of the Universe report with Michael Turner

The Origins Podcast with Lawrence Krauss

About This Episode

June 26, 2024

•

1 hr 57 min 16 sec

Michael Turner has been one of the leading pioneers in the emerging field of particle-astrophysics: the effort to understand the large scale properties of our universe by exploring the fundamental microphysics that ultimately governed the earliest moments of the big bang. It has been an area in which most of my own research has been focused, so it is not surprising that Michael I became on and off research collaborators starting about 40 years ago. In 1995 Michael and I published a paper arguing that 70% of the energy of the universe must reside in empty space if the data at the time were to be self-consistent. Three years later two groups confirmed our prediction, and were awarded the Nobel Prize in 2011 for that discovery. Michael later coined the term “dark energy” to describe this completely mysterious quantity.

Michael is not only a leading scientist, he is also a leading expositor of astrophysics, having written one of the seminal books about the physics of the early universe, and he is frequently sought out by journalists to comment on current results, and by academic audiences for his popular lectures. He has a wry sense of humor, and over his more than 40 years of scientific research he has been involved in many of the key developments that have shaped astrophysics. He has also helped direct the national research effort itself, having been a deputy director of the National Science Foundation, and a former president of the American Physical Society.

Mike and I sat down for a long overdue discussion of his own perspectives on the field. We discussed his personal history, motivations, and challenges as a young scientist, and then went on to discuss many of the key areas of progress in cosmology over the past 40 years, including some puzzles which remain today, and about which one often reads in the popular press. For anyone interested in cosmology, our discussion will shed a great deal of light on which problems are real, and which are not, and also give a new perspective for how far we have come over the last half century in unraveling many of the mysteries of the universe.

As always, an ad-free video version of this podcast is also available to paid Critical Mass subscribers. Your subscriptions support the non-profit Origins Project Foundation, which produces the podcast. The audio version is available free on the Critical Mass site and on all podcast sites, and the video version will also be available on the Origins Project Youtube.

Get full access to Critical Mass at lawrencekrauss.substack.com/subscribe

Summary

This episode discusses the profound conversation between Lawrence Krauss and astrophysicist Michael Turner, highlighting Turner's groundbreaking research on dark energy and the universe's energy distribution. It explores Turner's significant role in unraveling cosmological mysteries and his personal history, emphasizing key developments, challenges, and educational influences. The narrative delves into the evolution of physics ideas, Turner's career decisions and collaborations, and the interplay of deuterium, dark matter, and nucleosynthesis in cosmology. Additionally, it delves into the complexities of measuring the Hubble constant, the quest to understand dark energy, and the social nature of science among physicists like Turner and Krauss.

Outlines

0:00:08Exploring the Mysteries of Cosmology with Michael Turner

This section delves into a profound conversation between Lawrence Krauss and the esteemed astrophysicist Michael Turner. Turner's impactful contributions to the field of particle-astrophysics are highlighted, including his groundbreaking research on dark energy and the universe's energy distribution. The dialogue captures Turner's significant role in unraveling cosmological puzzles over the past four decades, touching on key developments and challenges. The conversation offers insights into the progress of cosmology, emphasizing the vast strides made in understanding the universe's mysteries. Additionally, the podcast provides a rich narrative of Turner's personal history and motivations as a scientist, showcasing his expertise and engaging storytelling style. The episode serves as a comprehensive 'state of the universe report,' addressing fundamental cosmological concepts such as dark matter, Big Bang Nucleosynthesis, and current unresolved tensions in the field. Through their engaging discussion, Krauss and Turner offer a fascinating exploration of cosmology's evolution and the enduring enigmas that continue to intrigue researchers.

0:07:34Exploring Childhood and Educational Influences on Scientific Pursuits

This section delves into the formative experiences and educational journey of the individual, shedding light on how childhood environments, public school education, and family dynamics played pivotal roles in shaping his scientific interests. The narrative touches upon a unique childhood arrangement called Children's Paradise for divorced mothers, the transition to public schools in Los Angeles during the 1950s and 1960s, and the enriching impact of inspirational teachers in fostering a love for science. The individual's passion for electronics, ham radio, mathematics, and eventual fascination with physics at a young age are highlighted. The influence of family dynamics, including parental expectations and interactions, is explored, with anecdotes of encounters with renowned intellectuals as a backdrop. The narration concludes with a pivotal decision to pursue studies at Caltech, influenced by an early exposure to the institution's academic environment and ethos.

0:14:40The Evolution of Ideas in Physics

This section discusses the evolution of ideas in physics through personal anecdotes and experiences. It highlights the challenges and creativity associated with developing new concepts, emphasizing the significance of wrong papers and incorrect ideas in driving scientific progress. The narrative delves into the influence of prominent physicists like Feynman and the importance of youthful ignorance in fostering creativity and exploration of ideas. The conversation reflects on the dynamic nature of scientific discovery, illustrating how initial inaccuracies often lead to groundbreaking advancements and new avenues of exploration. Through various examples in physics history, the dialogue underscores the iterative and transformative nature of scientific thought, showcasing the process of refining and reshaping theories to uncover deeper truths about the universe.

0:22:35Michael Turner's Journey in Particle-Astrophysics and Cosmology

This section delves into the remarkable journey of Michael Turner, a pioneering figure in particle-astrophysics and cosmology. Turner's impactful collaborations and groundbreaking discoveries, including the identification of 'dark energy,' have reshaped our understanding of the universe. Through insightful discussions and personal anecdotes, Turner reflects on his scientific contributions, challenges faced as a young scientist, and the evolution of cosmology over the past four decades. His profound interest in cosmological questions and approach from the physics perspective underscore the immense significance of his research, shedding light on the mysteries of the cosmos.

0:29:41Michael Turner's Career Choices and Astrophysics Journey

This section narrates Michael Turner's journey in the field of astrophysics, highlighting significant career decisions and interactions with mentors. Initially faced with choosing between postdocs at Chicago and Harvard after being the 1st choice for both, Turner's mentors, including Dave Schramm and Bill Press, influenced his decisions. Despite considering a faculty job, Turner accepted a postdoc at Chicago on Schramm's advice. Turner's transition to Santa Barbara, encouraged by Schramm, further expanded his network and exposed him to key figures in his field. The summary also explores Turner's early research on big bang nucleosynthesis and baryosynthesis, illustrating the challenges and successes in cosmological studies.

0:37:29Understanding Dark Matter and Nucleosynthesis

This section delves into the complex interplay of deuterium, dark matter, and nucleosynthesis, highlighting the crucial role of deuterium abundance in distinguishing dark matter from ordinary matter. The discrepancy between dark matter and ordinary matter quantities reveals profound insights into the composition of the universe, with deuterium serving as a pivotal indicator. The discussion extends to the nuanced challenges in reconciling observations with theoretical frameworks, particularly in the context of precision cosmology. Insights from astrophysics and nuclear physics converge to shed light on the intricate processes governing the universe's evolution, emphasizing the meticulous balance between theory and observation in unraveling cosmic mysteries. The narrative also explores the enduring quest for precision in cosmological models, underscoring the evolving landscape of scientific inquiry and the relentless pursuit of understanding fundamental aspects of the cosmos.

0:47:07Unraveling Mysteries of the Universe

This section delves into the intriguing journey of physicists exploring the fundamental aspects of the universe, from the ambitious pursuit of understanding the energy distribution to the fascinating revelations in particle astrophysics. The narrative captures pivotal moments, like the prediction of 'dark energy' and the quest for grand unified theories, shedding light on the scientific endeavors that shaped cosmology. The text reflects on significant developments, from the anticipation of proton decay to the complexities of baryogenesis, painting a vivid picture of the dynamic landscape of theoretical physics. It highlights the transformative impact of groundbreaking ideas like inflation theory, emphasizing the collaborative nature of scientific discovery and the evolving perspectives that propel cosmological exploration forward.

0:56:55Key Ideas in Cosmology Conversations

This section narrates a conversation among physicists discussing pivotal moments in cosmology research. It delves into collaborations and breakthroughs in understanding the universe, including the concepts of inflation and the origin of cosmic lumps. By reflecting on the development of theories like new inflation and the implications for cosmic structure, the conversation highlights the significant role of scientific meetings, collaborations, and mathematical formalisms in advancing cosmological understanding over the past decades.

1:05:44Meeting with Steven and Andrei Linde

This section narrates a meeting filled with humor and intrigue, featuring Steven and Andrei Linde. The conversation reveals a unique gathering where Andrei Linde showcases his magical skills, attempting to change a person's appearance. Despite the playful atmosphere, discussions delve into profound cosmological concepts, including the uncertainties surrounding inflation theory and the search for fundamental truths in the universe. The narrative reflects on scientific discoveries, the elusive nature of beauty in theoretical physics, and the ongoing quest for a deeper understanding of the cosmos.

1:13:13Exploring Mysteries of the Universe with Michael Turner

This section delves into the complexities of cosmology, focusing on discussions about inflation theory, dark matter, and elementary particles. Michael Turner and Lawrence Krauss share insights on the limitations of current theories, the challenges of understanding the universe's secrets, and the pivotal role of dark matter in shaping our cosmic understanding. Touching on historical milestones and key developments, the conversation provides a nuanced perspective on the enigmatic components of our universe, emphasizing the ongoing quest for deeper comprehension.

1:21:49Challenges in Detecting Dark Matter and New Particle Possibilities

This section delves into the challenges of detecting dark matter particles and the exploration of new particle concepts like heavy neutrinos and axions. The conversation highlights the significance of particle physics in solving cosmological mysteries, with a focus on WIMPs and axions as potential dark matter candidates. The discussion also touches on the unpredicted absence of WIMPs at the Large Hadron Collider, leading to reevaluation of supersymmetry. The narrative shifts to the evolution of particle physics theories, emphasizing the beauty and falsifiability of scientific concepts. The dialogue between the experts reveals contrasting views on dark matter as either a singular solution or a gateway to a concealed realm, sparking contemplation on the future of cosmological discoveries.

1:30:37Cosmological Discoveries and Insights

This section delves into the intriguing realm of cosmology, highlighting significant advancements and perplexing mysteries unveiled over the past decades. From the pursuit to comprehend the universe's large-scale properties to the revelation of dark energy's enigmatic presence, the conversation between the two scientists offers a deep dive into the complexities and surprises within astrophysics. The dialogue touches on pivotal research collaborations, the emergence of dark energy as a dominant force, and the challenges in reconciling cosmological data with theoretical predictions. Through a captivating narrative that spans over 40 years of scientific exploration, the discussion sheds light on the evolution of cosmological understanding, emphasizing the persistent quest to unravel the universe's enigmas.

1:38:58Exploring Dark Energy and the Future of Cosmology

This section delves into the complexities of dark energy and the ongoing quest to understand the expansion rate of the universe. Discussions center around the variability of dark energy, challenges in precision cosmology, and various experiments such as the DESE instrument and the Rubin Observatory legacy survey. The conversation highlights the uncertainty surrounding dark energy's nature, with emphasis on the evolving perspectives and theories in the field of cosmology.

1:46:57Exploring the Mysteries of the Cosmos with Michael Turner

This section delves into the complexities of measuring the Hubble constant and the implications of dark energy in understanding the universe. The text touches on the significance of Lambda and early dark energy in cosmological models, highlighting the challenges and advancements in the field of astrophysics over the past four decades. The conversation between Michael Turner and Adam Riess provides insights into the ongoing puzzles and uncertainties in cosmology, emphasizing the importance of the Hubble constant as a fundamental parameter shaping our understanding of the expanding universe.

1:55:26Insights into the Social Aspect of Science

This section underscores the social nature of science, dispelling the misconception of solitary late-night work. The engaging discussion between Lawrence Krauss and Michael Turner reflects their shared enthusiasm for scientific inquiry and the collaborative essence of the field. They highlight the role of community support in advancing cosmology and reshaping perspectives. The dialogue not only illuminates the evolution of scientific understanding but also acknowledges the audience's vital contribution in fostering a profound comprehension of the universe.